"My purpose was simple: to catch the feel, the pulse of rock, as I had lived through it. What I was after was guts, and flash, and energy, and speed" - NIK COHN - ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- "When the music was new and had no rules" -LUNA C
Friday, February 27, 2009
THE HARDCORE CONTINUUM,
(a)Theory and Its Discontents
The text of a talk by Simon Reynolds delivered at FACT, Liverpool, Wednesday 11th February 2009.
notes for points to be brought up during the dialogue segment with Mark Fisher but weren't owing to time running out
afterthoughts on the past, present and future of the hardcore continuum
Thanks for coming out tonight. Thanks to curator Heather Corcoran and FACT for inviting me here, thanks also to my friend and colleague Mark Fisher from the Wire for his involvement, we will be having a discussion in a little while, I know he has a lot to say, lots of angles, and then we'll be throwing it open to questions from the audience.
But first, I'm going to talk about this little thing called the Hardcore Continuum Theory.
The first thing to note is that it's not a theory -- any more than Australia is a theory, or Jupiter is a theory. It's a fact, an objectively existent entity -- all I did was come up with a name for it, in the same way that someone came up with the name Australia and now the Australians are lumbered with it.
What the term describes is empirically verifiable, there is a body of testimony and reportage, all you need to do is talk to people involved at the various stages of this phenomenon--from hardcore through jungle and UK garage to grime, dubstep and bassline, and the continuum-ness of it is clear -- funky house, the latest emissions from the continuum is more debatable, it is a moot point whether that signifies the crumbling of the continuum. I'm not wholly convinced by that argument, but equally I'm not wholly convinced by the music, I'm sure we can discuss this heatedly later.
Now don't get me wrong, I'm not opposing to myself to theory, I'm all for theorizing, to me theory is the spice of critical life -- and the theory aspect to the Continuum discussion relates to the analysis of how this subcultural and musical entity came into being, what governs its development and mutation, where it fits into the grand scheme of music, and then there's speculation about where it might go next, which is fun but foolhardy because the continuum, in my experience, will always ambush you with some new twist, a mind-wrenching paradigm shift.
Theory or a critical perspective also comes into the picture when you get to some kind of assessment, or claim, in terms of what it means, what it's worth in the grand scheme of things--which I will get to doing later on
There is also perhaps a macro level, or meta level, where we can talk about how understanding music in terms of continuums applies beyond this specific example to other kinds of musical traditions, scenes, subcultures -- a sketch towards some kind general theory of the evolution of genres in popular music.
But okay, let's start with the basic facts, what I'm asserting precedes theory, the undeniable evidence. What is it that makes this continuum... continuous?
First there is a continuity of infrastructure -- as you came and took your seats some of you will have heard that track "Pirates Anthem" by Home T, Coco Tea, Shabba Ranks -- that is from 1989, 1990 I think, so just at the very moment before the continuum gets going-- and a key part of the infrastructural foundation for the continuum is pirate radio -- there are pirate radio stations that have shifted their music policies as the scene's music has gone through drastic changes .
Home T, Coco Tea, Shabba Ranks -- "Pirates Anthem"
A fantastic example here is Rinse FM, everyone I'm sure is aware that this stationshas been the don of grime and dubstep for the entire Noughties -- well Rinse FM started in 1994, it was a jungle pirate originally -- Rinse as you know if were on the scene then is an absolutely key jungle buzzword --- as in "rinse out the sound", "absolutely rinsing set Mr DJ" -- unlike for example Kool FM, which was the leading jungle pirate probably and which stuck with jungle, Rinse went garage in 1999 -- but that was at a point where garage was already becoming an MC dominated music, they had crews like Pay As You Go Cartel on their station, garage rap some called the sound then, and of course that turned into grime -- so Rinse becomes the leading station for grime and dubstep -- and right now Rinse is dominated by funky house and I believe is the leading pirate in London for funky -- now that fact in itself would seem to prove funky is part of the continuum.
Pirate radio is a key part of the enduring infrastructure, you also get certain promoters and clubs that carry on through all the musical changes -- record stores that change with each new shift, like Rhythm Division in the East End of London -- I don't know if dubplates are as important now but for a long, long stretch of the continuum's existence, deejays played a huge proportion of the music on their sets in the form of dubplates, and there was a specific place you went to get your dubplates cut and that was Music House in London.
Another running thread is the continuity of rituals -- the rewind, the role of the MC as accompaniment to the DJ. You do not get the rewind or the MC in forms of UK dance music such as house or techno or trance -- it's unique to the hardcore, jungle, garage tradition -- it comes from the sound system reggae-dancehall tradition originally, obviously.
What else is continuum-ous? There is a continuity of personnel, certain key figures keep cropping up, in a bit I will get into actual examples of artists who went through several successive phases of this music, changing their styles, you might say opportunistically but then if you said that you'd not be understanding the essence of this music, which is constant forward movement -- in with the new, out with the old.
There's not many figures who go all the way through, you tend to get people going from hardcore to jungle to UK garage… or from jungle to garage to grime…. or garage to grime to funky. HOWEVER I do have a jackpot example, which DJ Footloose, who actually runs through the entire history of the scene -- he started deejaying in 1992, played jungle clubs like Telepathy, the Roast, Thunder and Joy, he played on Kool FM, then in '98 he switched to garage, played on Déjà Vu and Freek two of the big speed garage stations, later graduating to shows on Kiss FM… he seems to have skipped grime but is currently one of the leading DJs for funky house, producing tracks and he presents the funky house show on 1xtra. So here you have a figure who must be getting on a bit now, in his late 30s, who runs the whole gamut from ardkore to funky house. Footloose can answer Zomby's question's "where were you in 92?". Because he was right there in the thick of the scene, and in 09 he's still there, in the thick of the scene. And that's because it is the same scene, essentially, fundamentally: the hardcore continuum.
There is also a continuity of population, the punters move with each new style shift … you'll not find many people who were into hardcore in 1990 and are into dubstep or funky now, that's because a lot of people drop out as they get to mid-thirties if not earlier, they can't hack the lifestyle any longer, but you will find a few, and there's many many people who went the whole journey from rave through jungle to garage and the early days of grime -- the grime MCs for instance were all influenced by the jungle MCs--Skibadee, Shabba, GQ, Dett, Moose -- that's who they cite as their prime influences, as opposed to American rappers.
Equally significant is the continuity of geography -- for most of the continuum's history, London is central. Greater London bleeding out into the Croydon type suburbs in the South and up into Essex and Hertfordshire. Which is where I'm from. Now strangely Hertfordshire is a stronghold of the continuum: a key jungle label Moving Shadow was based there as were artists like Omni Trio and also Source Direct who came from St Albans of all places. But that is really because of the new town, overflow town syndrome, you had proper Londoners, often East Londoners being shipped out to Herts, Kent, Surrey…
So it's London and surrounding counties. But it's never been just London, for sure there's been times when it has contracted pretty tight on the capital, even on the East End… but right at the start you had the North East involved, with bleep: that was the South Yorkshire and West Yorks cities, industrial towns with a good multicultural mix, a strong black population. Also Leicester where Formation Records and DJ SS were based.
For similar multicultural reasons you also had Bristol running through the whole lifetime of the continuum pretty much, from early jungle to dubstep -- Bristol is the second city of dubstep after London.
And you had the Midlands being a stronghold… Coventry in particular. Now for some reason not the North West really… I don't know why... Perhaps someone in the audience has a theory they can advance why Liverpool and Manchester haven't contributed much to the hardcore continuum.
So without wishing to be too Londoncentric, I'd say the continuum, as a creative force as opposed to people just liking the music, which you get all over -- all over the country, and all over the world -- but as a cultural engine that produces the music, it has been about London and the most London-like cities in the UK, in terms of their multiculturalism, their multiracialism.
Finally and perhaps most crucially there's been a continuity of sound and of attitude.
But before I get into that though, let's go right back to the start:
1989-1990, the UK rave scene is exploding -- at first it was really totally oriented around imports, house tracks from Chicago, techno from Detroit, garage and Todd Terry type hip-house stuff from New York… people in Britain started to imitate that music but it was a pretty straight copy at first and pretty second-rate, with a few exceptions, we must big up A Guy Called Gerald and 808 State and a few others ….. But really the first time the UK comes up with its own spin on house and techno is towards the end of 1989 - almost 20 years ago. Strangely how they do that is adding a bunch of elements that are actually not indigenous to the U.K. but would never have been let into the mix in Chicago or Detroit -- ideas from hip hop and electro, the booming 808 basslines… ideas from dub reggae and dancehall…. The first totally uniquely UK rave music stuff was bleep -- or bleep and bass as some called it -- from Yorkshire and the West Midlands: Unique 3, Sweet Exorcist, LFO, Nightmares on Wax, names that will, if you're a certain age, send a memory rush rippling down your spine.
Unique 3 were B-boys from Bradford, some of their early tracks have rapping on, not very good rapping admittedly, but there's a hip house feel, you could even hear those tunes as future ghosts of grime. They also had heavy heavy sub-bass, again that's like a future ghost of dubstep except it's also, simultaneously a past-ghost -- an echo down the years of sound systems mashing it down in Kingston, Jamaica.
Meanwhile at around the same time you had Shut Up and Dance in London, also hip hop influenced, big Public Enemy fans, making what they called "fast hip hop" . but almost against their own intentions their tracks became rave anthems. Shut Up and Dance were a group and a label, they had acts like the Ragga Twins who mashed together dancehall chat and searingly harsh European style techno, ragga-techno it was essentially, they weren’t alone doing that, there was Demon Boyz, who had a track called "Junglist" if I remember correctly, and there was Rebel MC.
And the Shut Up and Dance sound with the looped, uptempo, sped up breakbeats, some people called that 'breakbeat house', there were other groups doing that like Blapps Posse as well. This breakbeat house sound was the roots of jungle . And in fact a lot of the bleep records, although done with drum programming not breakbeats, had a skippy, syncopated feel to the rhythms, it wasn't a straight four to the floor house feel, it was almost like breakbeats done with drum machines.
Now breakbeat house and bleep, these UK-specific sounds, they come to be known as hardcore for a variety of reasons. The music is harder and more banging and more overtly druggy than the American stuff. Also the UK made tracks tend to really appeal to the most hardcore, full-on, pill-necking, drug monster ravers. It's hardcore cos the production values are quite low , it's white label music, not very polished, raw sounding, so it stays underground, most of it… It's not on the radio, or at least it is, but only on pirate radio.
At this stage people talk about hardcore house , that was actually a term believe it or not, or hardcore techno, then soon hardcore rave, and then just hardcore. Ardkore. Warp, who we think of in terms of electronic listening music, in those days they were pioneers of bleep and they called themselves hardcore early on, that's where they situated themselves.
Now the London version of hardcore would prove more influential in the long run than Northern bleep, because bleep was still quite acid and techno in vibe, quite dark and serious and minimal, but what Shut up and Dance brought in was this thing of very very cheeky samples from mainstream pop, massive chunks of uncleared samples -- and also SUAD loved movie soundtracks, they loved an orchestral sample -- and that is something that runs through the entire sweep of the continuum, you get funny little string refrains and pizzicato motifs in hardcore, in jungle, in 2step, in early grime, right now in bassline…..
A good recent example is Dok's "Rapid Speed" with its swashbuckling orchestral parts. Or from a few years ago Imp Batch's track "Gype Riddim" aka "Singalong" which is supposed to be a cut up of Prokofiev or somebody like that. This classical, orchestral thing is something YOU DO NOT GET IN PROPER HOUSE MUSIC, PROPER TECHNO, but this is improper music, it breaks the rules of propriety and property… if it's not nailed down it will be stolen by the hardcore continuum --
The poppy and chintzy sub-classical elements explain why you get this weird mix of rude and cheesy, ruffneck and sentimental, dark and soppy, running through the music, and you can pick that up from the visuals mostly scanned from my own collection that are showing on the big screen behind me -- this can be a tacky subculture.
Another thing that you get with the hardcore continuum that you don't get nearly so much with other forms of dance music, is that it has a sense of humour. A great spirit of playfulness. It's not afraid to be daft. To be silly, even.
One reason the breakbeats catch on more is they're initially easier to do than programming the drum machines so all kinds of teenage tearaways get involved and slam out a quick white label, make some fast money.
By '92 we've got piano riffs from Italian house and Belgian techno terror noises in the mix, and chartpop samples and movie score elements and all kinds of odd samples taken from these kids's parents' record collections -- Pink Floyd and old folk rock, you name it. But the basic coordinates of hardcore in this defining year of 1992 are a four way collision of hip hop and techno, reggae and house… It's like a multiple pile-up at a crossroads. And the BIG BANG releases this surge of energy: you have this crazy-fast evolution of hardcore into jungle, the development of breakbeat science and bass science -- the breaks get sped up, edited, processed, fantastically complex yet jagged yet groovy rhythms--- the bass gets more strange and peculiar, molded and gloopy, yet also punishing, and yet also heavy in a rootical sense, the dub reggae sense, there's a skanking feel in there too
Jungle continues on this path getting more intricate and extreme and pursuing lots of different directions and flavours, and by 1994-95 they're calling it drum'n'bass, (an act of self-inflicted gentrification if you ask me).
Next comes the big schism, the big paradigm shift, the thing that some people can't get their heads around, the switch to speed garage, which is 1996-1997.
It's actually a parting of the ways, drum'n'bass continues on its own path, which I see as a river branching off the continuum, and meanwhile a huge proportion of the London audience for jungle switches to a new sound UK garage or speed garage. It wasn't actually a new sound, if had existed in parallel with jungle for a few years in the mid-90s -- if you'd gone to a jungle club in those days, the chances are the second room, the chill out room, would have had garage, soulful house mostly made in America -- I never understood it at the time, it seemed a bit bland to me, but it was a mellower, more R&B sound, and gradually those second rooms got more popular as the drum'n'bass in the main arena got more punishing. The garage room would increasingly be where the women were. And the guys started thinking, hmmm I want to be in the room where the girls are.
Now at the same time pirates were playing garage at certain off peak times of the day and deejays who'd been through hardcore and jungle were really ruffing up the New York garage tracks, playing them at plus 8, playing the dubstrumentals -- the dub instrumental versions on the flipside --getting MCs to chat on top -- then they started making their own tracks, they were still sexy and much slower than jungle, but faster and tougher than New York garage -- and the producers would work in some jungle sounds: heavy basslines, ragga chat, mad effects. And that mix was called speed garage.
The best explanation of how jungle turned into UK garage and almost inverted itself while staying the same is the way the drum'n'bass label No U Turn opened a garage imprint called Turn U On. That's almost like a palindrome or something. It would be even better if No U Turn On had actually put out some killer garage that was anything near as good as their techstep releases. But that bit of wordplay captures the paradigm shift perfectly.
I'm going to take a pause for the cause here and play some music, to show the evolution and how certain figures recur at different stages:
Foul Play, "Dubbing U", from Vol. 2, 1992
Now that was Foul Play, "Dubbing U", from 1992. You can hear the reggae influence in there. "Dubbing U" is actually one of Burial's favourite tunes, a real ancestral track for him. Foul Play were a trio but Steve Gurley was perhaps at this point the driving force it would be fair say. And it's Steve Gurley whose trajectory we're going to follow.
Steve Gurley leaves Foul Play, lets them keep the name and he becomes Rogue Unit, under that name he does a lot of great remixes. Including this, which is effectively a bootleg remake of an Eighties R&B song by Princess "Say I'm Your Number One", not sure if it this remake was ever actually released, I have it on an old jungle compilation.
Princess, "Say I'm Your Number 1" (Exclusive Dubplate Special/Rogue Unit remix)
[I can't find the actual remix in question on the web but strangely there is another track by Rogue Unit from 1995 that samples "Say I You're Number One" -- Rogue Unit, "Good To You" -- I guess he really, really loved that Princess tune!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rGF82XgnPpA -- This version is quite different -- really really fierce, mashed-Amens style, good in its own way but nothing compares to the Exclusive Dubplate Special.]
Now I should have said one thing running through the whole of this music is actually soul -- female-voiced, usually, not always, but usually a diva from an old r&B or deep house record - the vocals won't be left alone like an American house producer would tend to, though, in the UK we mess around with stuff, so the voice gets get chopped up and resequenced, producers on the continuum become experts in creating a whole new emotional emphasis, as on the Princess track, the original is completely different in vibe, you can find it on youtube pretty easily and it's a much more placid song, whereas the Steve Gurley remake has this bursting edge-of-hysteria quality, which is much more suited to rave culture... the kind of feelings that come out of Ecstasy.
And then as we get to UK garage and 2step more and more there's processing on the vocals, there's micro-editing, turning the human voice into percussion, vocal science as a friend of mine, Bat, dubbed it -- But even through all this cyborg manipulation which it's always fun to talk about, always there is this soul power --a kind of hypersoul, maybe -- and that runs through the whole continuum, from hardcore to bassline -- and for various cultural reasons that are interesting to think about, it's the female voice that is the privileged representation of bliss -- so we have this current of feminine pressure running through the continuum -- indeed when the voices start to drop out of the music completely, then I think we're in trouble, then it's starting to be a river branching off the continuum, as with drum and bass, as with dubstep. Then it starts to have international appeal, the less soulful it is -- funnily enough. Your international white boys contingent don't like the divas, it doesn't compute for them, they think that kind of singing makes it pop music, or R&B. And they probably haven't done enough Ecstasy to feel that hypersoul rush.
And then in the garage era Steve Gurley -- perfect name really for someone operating with feminine pressure and divas -- he pops up again using his own name doing remixes like this one
Baffled and Operator, "Things Are Never (Steve Gurley Remix", 1998
audible here http://classichousemusic.blogspot.com/2008/01/operator-baffled-things-are-never-steve.html
[check out also this equally massive Gurley remix of the era -- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JdccX4BJCqc -- his 2step version of Lenny Fontana's "Spirit of the Sun"]
So once again, as with the first two tracks, you can hear the reggae thing in the bass, and the whole vibe is sensual yet ominous, the lyric goes "things are never/ quite the way/they seem" which is tinged with paranoia. Sexy dark garage is what I'd call this track.
Now after I finished this CD for the talk I stumbled on a track by Steve Gurley called 'Hotboys', it appears on a compilation CD called The Roots of Dubstep, put out by Tempa Records…
Steve Gurley, Hotboys, circa 2000
And in fact tying in with my thesis about dubstep losing the diva vocals, that track doesn't have a vocal on in fact.
So there you have one producer who goes from hardcore through jungle, through speed garage, to be a foundational figure in dubstep, and for all I know he's still out
there, making funky house tracks. Steve Gurley: he's not that well known outside the scene, but he is one of the all time pantheon.
Next up, another god-like figure, Chris MacFarlane. First I know of Chris Mac is this track on the Ibiza label from '92, he's calling himself Bad Girl, that's just one of his alter-egos, and the track is "Bad Girl."
Bad Girl, "Bad Girl" (Ibiza, 1992)
So that's hardcore, with the sped-up squeaky chipmunk voice, but quite a junglistic feel, jungle techno they'd have called that it in 92, and you would never get that kind of bassline in techno from outside the UK.
Next he's gone from being Bad Girl to calling himself Potential Bad Boy, here's a burst of "Let's Go" from the Work the Box EP, this would be late 93 and it's a more junglistic track.
Potential Bad Boy, "Let's Go", Work the Box EP, Limited Edition E, 1993
And here he is again in 1998, under his own name finally, Chris Mac, "Plenty", doing 2step garage.
Chris Mac, Plenty, 1998
That's 2step garage, so it's a lot more poised and slick than the hardcore/jungle style, and yet there's continuities, the use of the vocals, the air of hysteria, and also there's a kind of hyperkinesis to the music, even though 2step's dancing tempo is approximately half the tempo of hardcore, it's got all these twitchy elements, it's almost as though the speed and convulsiveness of hardcore and jungle has been imploded into the music.
Now if you were to look at these guys, Steve Gurley and Chris Mac from a distance, if you didn't know anything about this area of music, you might say "goodness gracious me, what opportunists these chaps are, they jump from one style to another, where's their artistic integrity?". But they are just going with the flow of the continuum, carried along by its currents, and the point of the continuum is, it doesn't stay still, ever. Indeed you stay true to it by being stylistically faithless--inconstant.
And finally here's another recurring figure, someone who keeps moving and grooving all through this period, a fellow called Grant Nelson. Under the name Wishdokta he did a lot of rave tunes for the label Kickin' but from what I understand he was already making UK garage tunes in the early to mid nineties--closer to the US model of garage, nothing like speed garage really, but still, precocious fellow, eh? And during the mid-90s he was making happy hardcore, in partnership with a guy called Vibes who was the biggest happy hardcore DJ at one point -- so Grant's got fingers in many pies. Instead of a Wishdokta tune though I'm going to play a track by someone else that Grant Nelson produced-- Xenophobia's "Rush in the House"--for reasons that will become apparent.
Xenophobia, "Rush In the House", Kickin' 1992
So Grant Nelsons's enjoying a lot of success on the hardcore scene and happy hardcore but in '97 he really makes a name for himself with fabulous speed garage anthems under various names. Like this one:
N&G, "Liferide", 1997
That features Rose Windross, the sister of Norris the Boss Windross, and she sang with Soul II Soul early on -- the MC is Creed, one of the great UK garage MCs. But you see why I played Xenophobia, cos that track had an MC, MC Scallywag, rapping about Ecstasy. And you see how the MC thing runs through the whole of the continuum. And with UK garage you have all these star MCs like Creed, but what's significant about "Liferide" is that Creed is rapping some proper verses in that song. It's no longer just a few catchphrases. And you get more and more MCs doing that over garage and 2step and that is the beginning of grime.
One more from Grant Nelson, as Bump N Flex he did this 2step monster in 1999
Bump N Flex featuring Jean McClain, "'Step 2 Me"
Now when speed garage happened you could say it was American house music momentarily overpowering the continuum to an extent, but with 2step the jungly, UK-only thing reasserts itself. Here on "Step 2 Me" it's like jungle and house are fighting to control the track. That bass drop is just pure junglism, I can't tell you how many tracks in 95 and 96 had a sort of rolling feel to it. And then fighting back, you get that flickering keyboard lick coming in that's pure garage. But also there is a really brief sample of Foul Play, a tiny snippet of synth from this gorgeous track they did after Steve Gurley left, 'Being With You' from late 1994. Now why would Grant do that? It didn't really add much to the track -- well, it's there for those who know, it's deliberating emphasizing the continuity for the community. And 'Being with You' is a classic soul-powered diva jungle track, sampling Mary J. Blige, if I remember right.
Now there are those who would say "well, look these so-called continuum producers, they're sampling R&B vocals, with 2step they're nicking rhythmic ideas from Timbaland, early on you had influences from hip hop, you've got reggae and dancehall as a constant feed-through of ideas. You also had Belgian hardcore techno as a big influence early on and it keeps cropping back with techstep drum'n'bass, even with early grime."
They would say, "It makes no sense to isolate this strand of UK music separate from what's going on in the wide world of music." And if they've read some Deleuze and Guattari, some Sadie Plant--and they usually have--they'll say that a much better way to see music is rhizomatically, everything connects to every else, all music is connected to all other music. Music's not about roots, it's more like a bed of nettles, it works through lateral connections. Rhizomes -- in the horticultural sense.
To which I retort, well obviously these people are influenced by stuff outside the continuum, how could they not be? We're all of us inundated from pop music from every side, and these are musicians, they're sensitive to this stuff, they're going to be turned on by new ideas wherever they're from.
But the key point-- and it's so obvious really--is that when these people in jungle or garage or grime or bassline make their tracks, who are they making their tracks for, in terms of an audience? And who are they making their tracks against, in terms of who is their competition?
DJ Hype might have sampled people like the Wu Tang Clan and G-funk, but when he made a track he wasn't thinking of competing with Wu Tang Clan or Dr Dre on their terrain, that wouldn't be realistic and that wasn't his goal. DJ Hype's focus was on making a tune to spar with the latest production by Andy C, Ray Keith, Asend --people on the jungle scene.
And Wiley and Dizzee and other grime people, for sure they've listened to American rap. They'd dig certain US rappers and they'd steal rhythm ideas and production ideas from Swizz Beats and Neptunes and other street rap producers from the States. But when they make a tune they're not trying to compete with those guys, that terrain is way way out of their reach. No, Wiley is sparring with other grime producers like Terror Danjah or Lethal Bizzle. That is their battle zone--the grime scene.
So that is one way to conceptualise the continuum: as a contest, a competition, a game. Like a sport even. Indeed this music actually has rules, it's not a free for all, not at all. Producers on the scene sometimes spout that kind of talk, about how there's no rules in this genre, "we can do anything". But in actual fact if you look at the music at any given point, it is quite tightly formularized. Tracks have to be within a really quite restricted beats-per-minute range, they had to have a certain rhythmic feel; if you didn't have, say, particular drops in the track, DJs couldn't use them. So at any given point there was a range within which you operated, and creativity was bending those rules, not breaking them. It's easy to break the rules, easy to totally disregard the functional requirements of the music.
This is how the hardcore continuum works, and how all continuums work. Through the pressure of peers: a spirit of mostly friendly, occasionally vicious rivalry between people who more often than not know each other. In the early days of writing about jungle I hung out with Goldie a bit and I was always struck by how often other producers seemed to figure in his imagination in this almost phantasmic way, like he was engaged in one-sided wars with people who might not have felt the same about him at all, or even been aware there was this competition going on. Goldie talked about how he was competing with a guy called Cool Hand Flex, a producer who's hardly remembered now. Now perhaps Goldie felt threatened 'cos Flex was doing a few tunes that had a jazzy fusion element, which Goldie felt was his agenda with songs like "Angel". So Cool Hand Flex would be encroaching on what was going to be his territory. And Goldie alluded to having had similar sparring feelings towards Foul Play and DJ SS at certain points, and also a really obscure outfit called Bodysnatch. At the same time these were people he rated highly, as the competition, the guys to beat.
But it's actually the same in most music scenes if you look at the history of music -- in the Sixties the Beatles, Stones, Beach boys, were all checking out each other's stuff, trying to race ahead of each other, responding to or stealing each other's ideas. If you read Alex Ross's book on 20th Century classical, figures like Mahler and Schoenberg, you see these composers often knew each other personally, they followed each other's work with very keen interest, it was about keeping up with each other, outflanking each other, sometimes taking each other's ideas and doing them better.
And perhaps this is a good point to point out that this hardcore continuum is just one continuum among many in music. You could talk of a jazz continuum, or multiple jazz continuums. A metal continuum. The UK hardcore continuum isn't the only continuum in dance music either, you could talk of a trance continuum, a deep house one, a minimal techno one, a number of other dance continuums. It's even not the only dance continuum I'm interested in as a listener or as a writer, for instance I've written a lot about another music called hardcore, the gabba tradition, European four to the floor kick drum pounding terror techno, I'm a big fan and defender of that. And that other hardcore is pretty separate from the UK hardcore continuum, although they intersect at various points. But you know I've even had some kind things to say about trance at certain points! But some people seem to get this idea that this music is the only thing I value, which isn't true even in dance music, let alone the whole world of music. But I would say for me the hardcore continuum is definitely the most consistently thrilling and thought-provoking strand of British dance music.
It's also never been my contention that this hardcore continuum is sealed off from other music, that it's this impermeable thing. Influences seep in but they are assimilated -- they become fuel for the furnace of a struggle between peers for supremacy, to be the don of the scene.
So I would further argue that a healthy musical continuum is one where everyone involved is listening to everybody else very closely, but they're not ONLY listening to people inside the scene. They're tuned to stuff outside it, and then they use that stuff from outside as part of their arsenal against the other producers within the scene who are their rivals.
An unhealthy continuum is one where people are listening closely to each other, but they're ONLY listening to each other. That happens a lot with musical traditions, they become enclosed, purist. That might well be what happened to drum'n'bass after 1997.
But talking about competition, rivalry, jousting -- let's move onto rival theories, different ways of mapping how music works. Now I could hardly fail to have noticed that recently there's been some people who've been kvetching, grumbling a bit about this idea of a hardcore continuum, on the ground that it's maybe overly… legislative, perhaps is the word. And some of them are proposing this counter-theory I referred to earlier, the rhizomatic, everything-connects-to-everything-else outlook. Now to be honest this seems a bit dated to me, it's very 90s, very Mondo 2000, it makes me think of that period when you could get smart drinks at rave. But the main thing is that I think this theory appeals to certain people - those who happen to be DJs or producers -- because it casts their artistic practice in a flattering light. They can be the brave, free spirited artist who isn't chained to a particular scene or style. Once upon a time people like that were known as gadflies, dilettantes! But the thing that interests me about this particular theory -- if you can call it that, because there's not much to it -- is that it instantly deconstructs itself. These people are dependent on the existence of genres as relatively stable entities so that what they do in terms of mixing this and matching that -- yawn, it seems so un-enticing really doesn't it? -- can seem audacious and naughty and clever. They would not even exist as artists without these genres whose boundaries they purport to scorn. Not only are they literally parasitic on all these genres -- the hardcore continuum genres, the shanty house genres like carioca funk and kwaito and juke and baltimore breaks, what some people call the global ghetto tech genres --but they are philosophically dependent on them. The valorization of unrootedness, or uprootedness, is dependent on the existence of the rooted, which can be denigrated in comparison to their marvellous mobility and freedom. It's perfectly obvious why they wouldn't want to to go along with a theory that emphasizes continuity through time and an element of geographical groundedness.
Now I do try hard to be fair so I'm going to attempt to see why those theories and the artistic practice that accompanies them might appeal, where its element of idealism is. And I would say that it relates to a utopianism of space--that's really what makes it so 1990s, so early days of the web--the idea of connectivity, of postgeographical flows, of things that are remote being brought close, the separate and far-flung become one in the mix.
Now the hardcore continuum operates through a different kind of utopianism, not constituted through space but through time. Oh, it does have a romance of place--the Just 4 U London thing. But I think time is the crucial axis. I always come back to this phrase I use a lot, the title of a track by a hardcore outfit called Phuture Assassins: "roots 'n' future". If you look at the hardcore continuum you can see a consistent impulse running through it that simultaneously casts backward to the past and forward to the unreachable horizon of the future. So you have roots, and roots in the most obvious sense mean Jamaica and the sound system tradition, but also, and I've noticed this with people in this scene, that when you interview them they often have a sense of legend, a sense of a hallowed and halcyon past, they'll talk in misty-eyed terms about raves or tracks from long, long ago, meaning five years ago -- like one of the flyers showing on the screen, don' t know if it's been projected yet, is for a Back to 91 Rave, but it was a Back to 91 Rave that took place in early 1995… so that's like only four years previously! And often producers and DJs and MCs when you interview them see to have a sort of grand sense of themselves as heroic figures with storied, glorious pasts, these are people who are sometimes only 22 and they're talking about "back in the day", about things they did when they were seventeen, their first tracks they made or spat on.
But there'll also be this thing all the way through this culture of reaching out to tomorrow, "living for the future" as Omni Trio put it. Or, "We bring you the future, the future, the future" by Noise Factory. It's like people in the scene have a heightened and highly charged sense of temporality...
This utopianism of time is something that threads through the culture in strange loops because when you listen, as a fan, to stuff from all across its breadth and length, you sometimes get these uncanny timewarp sensations--you hear things in 1990 bleep tune that are future-ghosts of sounds in grime or dubstep or bassline. It's almost like any track from any point in the continuum contains all the past and all the future of this music inside it. Like DNA or something.
And then as well as these accidental echoes, you also get deliberate homages in more recent music harking back to the old skool days. Burial's music is only a self-conscious, scholarly version of this syndrome.
So I'm going to play some examples of this kind of homage:
Jonny L, "Hurt You So" 1992
This was one of those hardcore rave tunes that people expected would be a hit, it was massive on the pirates, had all the potential to crossover, but it didn't.
So Jonny L goes off and does various things, disappears for a bit, then comes back in 1996 doing this sick, punishing, ultra-minimal drum'n'bass.
Then speed garage happens and we get this record
Fabulous Baker Boys, "Oh Boy", 1997
So you have the same vocal as in "Hurt You So" and there's other melodic elements and arrangemetn motifs of the original tune reused too. There's a couple of aspects to this: one is just recycling, a good tune is a good tune, but also I think there is conscious homage, because there were loads of hardcore remakes done by speed garage and 2step outfits. I almost think of them as being orientation devices for the scene, there's been this massive paradigm shift to a much slower kind of groove with speed garage but this is affirming that it's still a continuum, in fact it may even be saying UK garage is more true to hardcore than drum'n'bass in 97 was, because speed garage had the blissful female vocals and drum'n'bass had dropped the vocal science element, the divas had departed from drum'n'bass completely.
Now Jonny L notices his tune's getting reworked and he plunges into the 2step garage scene doing stuff under the name Truesteppers, with this guy called Andy Lysandrou, who used to be a hardcore producer under the name Kid Andy. And then the Truesteppers name really takes off with this single "Out of Your Mind" featuring Victoria Beckham and--Autotuned to fuck--Dane Bowers. And this record got to Number 2in theUK charts in 2000!
Truesteppers featuring Victoria Beckham and Dane Bowers, "Out of Your Mind", 2000
So Jonny L finally gets his hit record...
And what an amazing production, you can hear the nasty bass sounds that are pure techstep drum'n'bass, and little bursts of jungle style breakbeats, chopped up Amen breaks that are pure 1994 Amen-smashing junglism, and also that little orchestral snippet running through the whole thing, like I said a running thread through the whole continuum, this sub-classical penchant.
And what makes it even more interesting for me as the nutty nuum scholar that I am is the involvement of Kid Andy, he had founded a hardcore rave label called Boogie Beat way in 1990, and in 1992 I remember something really unusual, you had ads on the pirates mostly for upcoming raves, almost never for a track that was coming out but they had an commercial for a new tune from Kid Andy and Nickelbee called "Pain", they clearly thought it was going to be massive, everyone would run out to the shops and buy it and it would get in the charts. And "Pain" was basically George Michael 'Careless Whispers' over a breakbeat. George was still a pretty massive pop star then. And in a funny sort of way that Kid Andy fantasy comes true cos he's essentially slung a riddim track under Posh Spice -- who in 2000 is probably the biggest pop celebrity in the UK, just post Spice Girls this is, and they had instore signing sessions all over the UK for "Out of Your Mind" with Posh and Becks signing the single. But what really interests me is why she did it? Why did she get involved in a record that would otherwise have been a pretty underground tune? Well, it shows the power of the hardcore continuum, 2step was so massive in 2000 it was a good move in terms of credibility, she wanted to be part of it.
And just briefly as an aside, here's a little burst of what Jonny L was doing immediately before going 2step -- "Piper", his techstep drum'n'bass classic
Jonny L, "Piper", 1997
Now interestingly there is a female vocal in here but it's completely devoid of soul, Dalek-like, dead, just like the groove which is this lifeless, if quite impressively stiff beat. This style of drum'n'bass -- neurofunk is what I called it -- is basically the music that made speed garage need to come into existence. And from speed garage we get dubstep, we get grime, we get bassline, we get funky.
So now we move to the stage I alluded to earlier, beyond the facts, beyond even the analysis and the theorization, towards the claims you can make for this music. My final oration, as it were.
People ask me, "why are you so obsessed with this music Simon?" At first I've nothing to say, it's self-evident isn't, just listen to the music, I could just have not said a word and played you 20 tunes and you'd have understood, I'm sure. But I can't get away with that, and I'm not a deejay. So, okay, here why it's so important. There's two sides to this, the objective and the personal.
Objectively, I stake my claim here that this music has been our equivalent to hip hop and our equivalent to reggae. By which I mean, a musical system that endures while evolving at an insane rate. If you look at all the changes hip hop's been through, from the late 70s to the early Noughties, it's incredible, or look at Jamaican, the journey from ska to rocksteady to roots reggae and dub to dancehall to ragga -- unbelievable. And interestingly just like the hardcore continuum, hip hop and Jamaican music also have this "roots 'n' future" thing of referring back while always looking forward. So there's a utopianism of time, maybe even a messianic conception of time: the promised land that is behind us and ahead of us. And this obviously relates to aspects of the black experience, and also to Christianity, the mystical strains of Christianity as they've fed into Rastafarianism and into the Baptist and Pentecostal traditions in America that had such a big influence of Black American music.
Now I love hip hop, and I love reggae and dancehall, but I couldn't be part of them, I'd always be loving them from the outside. Whereas the UK thing, for all its roots in mostly black music and its background as mostly --not exclusively-- but mostly working class culture, the UK thing has been something I could be part of.
So I can say truthfully this is the greatest musical thing I've ever witnessed with my own ears and my own eyes. I mean, I love Sixties music but I was small child then. I wasn't a small child during postpunk but I lived in a small town and a lot of it I missed, as subculture, there weren't many gigs where I lived, most of the key bands of the era I never saw perform, so postpunk was mediated through records, the radio, the music press. But the hardcore continuum, I experienced the early years of it and even after moving to America was still able to dip into it as a full experiential participatory thing on a regular basis.
So that brings us round to the personal aspect, which is not a claim but just pure testimony. What can I say? Outside my wife and family, I 'd have to say this music has given me the best years of my life.
The hardcore years… just crazy adventures, a rollercoaster of experience, I was disoriented, hurled into this vortex, barely understanding what this music was. I never went to clubs to see particular DJs I just went along for the adventures you'd have.
Then the jungle years, by this point it was more mapped out, I was more aware and informed -- I'd say my mode shifted by that point to being a scholar-soldier --that's the second phase of music fanaticism, when you start to know who the auteurs are, the DJs and the producers and the key labels, you're piecing together the history of the scene. I was a fanatic, a patriot, for jungle -- and I would have put junglist on my passport at that point.
And then speed garage -- what that was like was, imagine you were in love with someone, you thought they were beautiful beyond compare, you loved all their little mannerisms and expressions, quirks and secrets… and then you woke up one morning, and your lover had turned into a completely different person, just as beautiful, as adorable, but with different features and quirks and mannerisms, BUT underneath somehow the same person, the same soul. Quite disorienting, to wake up like that, but then equally a wonderful gift, the opportunity to fall in love all over again without losing the thing you originally loved. So that was speed garage, jungle in new flesh, jungle reincarnated.
And then 2step... Now if you love someone, you want the best for them,right? If my wife was suddenly made the editor of Vogue I'd be so proud and pleased for her. Well, that's what it was like when 2step, after 18 months bubbling on the overground, just completely took over the pop charts in 1999 and 2000
And grime…. That was like waking up in the morning and finding your partner has turned into Godzilla. And yet you still love her, it's still the same soul underneath the monstrousness.
I've possibly extended this metaphor perilously far, but you can see I identify with this culture very strongly, I feel wedded to it.
With my music critic's hat on I think of it as musically the most impressive thing to come out of the UK in the last couple of decades. And with my cultural critic's cap on, I think it's in a lot of ways the most hopeful thing that's come out of the UK's multiculture.
And yet for all that I wouldn't be devastated if it just crumbled away, as it might well do, and sooner rather than later. It has had a very good run, it really is 20 years now, if we think of Unique 3's 'The Theme' coming out in 1989. That is a long time for a musical formation to hold it together and stay interesting. Does it have new surprises up its sleeve, or is it going to disintegrate into different directions? It could split up into separate streams that go their own merry way, and some of them might merge with other musical traditions.
Funky is the first thing ever from the continuum that I've not been swayed and slayed by, it's where I feel like maybe they've left behind too many of the key elements from the mix. It's a bit too tasteful for me. I'm biased in London's favour, I'm a London patriot generally, but I really feel like the last few years the North has been carrying the banner of the continuum. Bassline has everything that I most love about this music: the rudeness and the cheesy-ness, it has the bass madness and the MCs and the blissful female vocals. So in a lovely sort of way that is a circle being completed-- back to the bleep days -- to Sheffield Leeds Bradford Nottingham running things again.
So I want to end my talk and set up the next bit with Mark Fisher by playing a tune that is totally London oriented, the tune is by Gant and it's called "'Soundbwoy Burial", a speed garage classic from 1997.
Gant, "Soundbwoy Burial (187 Lockdown Dancehall Mix)", 1997
But interestingly if you go on YouTube the person who posted this tune describes it as speed garage but also as a Niche anthem -- Niche in Sheffield being the legendary foundational club for bassline house. So this track which is so London oriented, the MC starts by calling out to the four corners of the city, North East South and West, yet it is an ancestral tune for bassline and for the whole Northern extension of the continuum. It's a hinge track, for me, it came out almost midway in the historical span of the continuum, and in it you can hear things that cast back to bleep, ardkore, jungle, but also things that look forward to grime, dubstep, to bassline -- obviously, with that crazy warped bassline -- and maybe even to the slinkiness of funky.
That's why they call it a continuum folks!
NOTES FOR KEY POINTS FOR THE DIALOGUE WITH K-PUNK SECTION
the starting point of the continuum circa 1990, and what preceded it or laid the foundations
The prehistory of the continuum is when the music is mostly not UK homegrown. So that would include Eighties street beats culture (almost entirely based on imported music --anything from America basically: rap, electro, early house). And it would include the Eighties boom of tower block pirates in London and other cities: playing first reggae and soul, then hip hop, then house. All the stuff BBC Radio and commercial radio wasn't catering for. Urban music. But again they'd be mostly playing non-UK tunes. The one pre-history element that is uniquely British is the fast chat style of MCing in the UK reggae scene, Saxon Studio International, with MCs like Tippa Irie (who would indeed later resurface chatting on UK garage tunes and also worked with The Bug), Asher Senator, Papa Levi, and most famously, Smiley Culture. These MCs would mix up Jamaican patois with London slanguage in a way that seems totally proto-nuum.
the national versus international dialectic
I would almost say that the more international success the sound has the more it starts to get severed from the continuum. Like drum'n'bass -- I remember where there was a big convention organized of drum'n'bass from all around the world, it was 98, 99, I think. Drum'n'bass fans from all over Europe, places like Croatia, from Australia, from Brazil, you name it. And D&B had become very strong in North America by then and even now still is going as a scene. But I think by 1999 drum'n'bass stopped having much to do with the continuum anymore. There were still a few D&B pirates but it was not the Sound of London anymore, garage was. In the UK, drum'n'bass's audience was increasingly nationwide and included a lot of students. It was almost bigger everywhere BUT London.
Re. the national versus international dialectic, conversely speed garage, 2step, didn't really spread beyond the UK. Grime got a sort of global hipster following but never established roots anywhere else. Funky I really don't think will spread beyond London.
Some things manage to transplant and others don’t take in the foreign soil: jungle caught on, I think, because it was helped by the fact that rave had happened to some extent in America, ecstasy had prepared people for really fast music, really mental sonic delirium, and so a contingent of US ravers followed the breakbeat line from things like the Prodigy. 2step and grime didn't really take off in America -- there were really good scenes for 2step in New York and a few other cities that prospered for a few years but never got past the problem of being dependent on imports from the UK, and the economics of flying name DJs in from the UK. Grime similar. Dubstep seems to be doing okay in America as it does in other outposts around the world. It's prospering as a hipster sound --- I think because it's so close to drum'n'bass, it's got the roots reggae thing, it's more techy, it's also got more of that progressive discourse around it.
I sometimes think of the hardcore continuum as being like a rocket, it sheds all these stages as it hurtles into the beyond. It is so burning with fertility it can just shed these sounds behind it -- drum'n'bass, dubstep, happy hardcore -- and they will have a reasonably vital existence on their own. Or they're like streams off a river. Big enough to be considered rivers in their own right, sometimes. It's also possible that the nuum river itself will dry up or form a stagnant dead sea, while the separated-out streams will carry on, or merge with some other rivers of sound.
Factors of change #1: Drugs.
Drugs don't seem to be as central to the continuum in the way they did for most of the Nineties, the energizing role of Ecstasy is obvious, the way it created fervor and belief, allowed for social mixing on an unprecedented kind . And then the decline of E and the dominance of weed with jungle, leading to a darker, moodier, paranoid vibe.
And then the rise of cocaine and its links to 2step garage, more upful, glamour-oriented, frantic in its desirousness. But do the newer styles -- grime, bassline, funky--have specific relationship with particular drugs? There's that rumour about wonky and ketamine, but that may just be myth, like the myth of jungle and crack. Overall it's seems much more to be a casual pick'n'mix of the established menu of drugs, with no particular sonic correlates or consequences. Drugs don't seem to be driving anything particularly at the moment. That's the sense I get anyway, I could be wrong.
Factors of change #2: Gender
I think by and large the "feminine pressure versus masculine armor" dialectic is sound and holds a good deal of explanatory power. What I've described as a self-corrective pendulum within the nuum. Or even a pendu(nuum)luum! So Martin Clark uses that kind of self-correction notion to characterize the inverted relationship between grime and funky, with funky being the return to "feminine, escapist, 'mature raver,' warm, anodyne, danceable, tracky, DJ-focused, shoes/shirts" in reaction to grime which was "masculine, reflectist, 'yout,' hard, raw, watchable, MC-focused, hoods/trainers".
That said, one has to be careful and not get to caught up in theoretical grids at the expense of empirical data: for instance, although techstep and dubstep both seem masculinist, stripping away the vocal science and the diva bliss, I was always surprised by how many women were into the harder drum'n'bass direction. Dubstep does seem like blokestep, but then again there's always quite a lot of women at the dubstep things I've been too. Perhaps because it's such a harmless blokey, nonthreatening atmosphere…. it is all JUST about the music. In dubstep the pressure to be glammed up and club babelicious doesn't exist; you're not going to get hit on when you go to a dubstep party.
Factors of change #3: Race
I've said above that I think of the hardcore continuum, from rave through jungle to UK garage to grime and beyond, as being one single culture; that it's our equivalent to hip hop, or to the Jamaican continuum (ska to reggae to dancehall…). But the crucial difference between the UK thing and those other countries is that the hardcore continuum is multicultural. You could say that musically it's dominated by black influences, but in terms of its population it's a mixture of black, white, Indian subcontinent, you name it. I'm always amazed by the mix of people involved in these scenes: grime has a lot of people of African descent involved, which is culturally quite different from people whose parents or parents' parents came from the Caribbean. You'd come across London-bred Cypriots in the UK garage, Turkish kids, people from all kinds of places. And a lot of people who are just mix-race, all sorts of blends. It seems that as more and more racial groups join, the centrality of the Jamaican influence has weakened somewhat. It's still there but other things are jostling with it now.
Factors of change #4: Technology.
The role of the web has really started to seriously undermine the territorialism of the music, its localism. Until really quite recently it was quite hard to be into this music and follow it unless you've lived within its catchment area, meaning in range of the territorial broadcast of the pirates. You were dependent on mail ordering vinyl and mix-tapes at considerable expense and there was always a lag between what came out as recordings and what was actually pumping it out as the fresh, hot new music on the pirates. The prime of the Nuum, which I think was really from hardcore to the early days of grime, was pretty much pre-Web in terms of the internet actually having any real impact on how the scene functioned or on the nature of the music. I was thinking of how with my 1999 piece on 2step none of the labels or DJs or producers had web presence. I think I did one interview that was email and the rest was to mobile phones. Even with the early days of grime, 2002-2003, the music had hardly any web presence. I'm not sure 1Xtra existed then but certainly there was very little grime to be heard via the internet. The MySpace thing had not kicked off. Now though everybody has a Myspace, there's millions of tracks up there on YouTube, there's too many DJ sets and pirate radio sets uploaded on the web for you to process. Some pirates stream their broadcasts online, they have a dual existence that's both web and terrestrial radio -- Rinse FM is a good example. All the grime pirate radio sets I missed from earlier in the decade through living in New York are now being archived on the web! It's insane. So now it's about digital means of transmission, it's about music in your phone. The music has been deterritorialised. And that changes the game completely. It could be the downfall of the Nuum.
Personally I feel there is an almost ontological difference between terrestrial radio and net radio, I've never been able to get into the latter. I feel like tuning in from another timezone, at the wrong time of day for the show… it's just too displacing. And netradio loses that grandiosity of the broadcast to a potentially unlimited audience. It becomes like a niche thing, in the sense that it can be ignored, it's not invading the public airspace, being stumbled upon by horrified people who are unfamiliar with it, or indeed being stumbled on by people who then get fascinated and drawn into it. To tune into netradio you have to be preconverted to an extent. It's a niche thing, narrowcast by nature. For those who know. It's a new kind of postgeographical parochialism, where a narrowcast audience is scattered all across the globe.
Generally there seems to be a huge shift from analogue to digital. Analogue was vinyl, it was dubplates, it was cassette mixtapes, it was pirate radio broadcasting through the airwaves. But vinyl is fading, mixtapes now mean CDs and soon will just be downloads of DJ sets; the music goes straight into people's phones.
You can see this analogue-to-digital shift play out particularly with bassline:
the Northern sound is much less tied to pirate radio. Cities like Birmingham and Manchester and Leeds do have pirates, but only a few compared with the scores that there are in London; the pirates have never been the engine of the culture in the way they are in the capital city. Instead, bassline propagates itself through "mixtape" (actually burned CD-Rs), MySpace, and YouTube. With the latter, there are sometimes videos, cheaply made and frankly rubbishy-looking affairs (in some cases seemingly filmed on a mobile phone not a video camera). But more often than not, there's just a still image (again, often snapped with a phone) that stays frozen while the audio element, the bassline track, rolls along. Bassline producers, deejays and MCS have cleverly jacked YouTube and turned it into a free, legal substitute for pirate radio as a means of getting their music out there.
The future of the pirates
And yet, despite all the above, Martin Clark -- someone on the ground and whose take I would very much trust--and who plays on a pirate station -- thinks they're still important:
" I still strongly believe the answer is 'yes.' Though there are less of them on the dials now, those pirates that remain have just responded to the technological challenges: Rinse has msn in the studio, a phone, myspace, a website, facebook and used to have a forum. It podcasts (http://www.rinsefm.blogspot.com/) and was on iTunes. I had a debate with Gee about this last summer when I asked him: how long would it be before the podcasts on Rinse were bigger than the listening audience? I ask this because we [Dusk and Blackdown's show] get more msn shouts than texts. But then we don't have a massive road following. Gee argued back that it depends massively on who is the audience we're talking about. if you're talking about what he calls the London 'ghetto' demographic, then the FM will always outweigh the online, and with the fact that online radio isn't available in cars, I can see his point. And with that point, it means influence.
"Basically, as Matt Mason's book points out, being a pirate is just a mentality, but the difference in a nuum context is it's a specific culture too, one that is accessible to the young road/urban/"ghetto" demographic, who can't and won't get on the BBC or commercial radio. So all the new technology just is a new forum of conduit for this mentality. Because despite all the technology I describe above, it doesn't explain why good music comes out of East London in itself, because by the nature of the democratisation of technology, it's everywhere. So why isn't funky coming out of Twickenham? Because it's a mentality within a demographic."
Donk hasn't got much to do with the hardcore continuum, in terms of its rhythms and its sounds, it's much more in the trance and hard house lineages. But it has a sort of ravey, defiantly cheesy sound that feels in the ardkore spirit. And it does have the MCs, speed-rapping in the rave MC style. The aesthetic of the rapping is about briskness and rapid-fire fluency, not vocal grain or charisma. That's why the boys in the Blackout Crew are so interchangeable. I think of donk as kind of adjacent to the hardcore continuum in the same way that the gabba tradition is.
Demographically and geographically it's squarely in the continuum, it's the next stage, there's overlap of personnel with earlier phases. But for me, it seems to have lost some of the values of hardcore: it's too mature, too slinky and sophisticated, I don't hear enough of the cheese or the rudeness. But the continuity between funky and grime is very clear, most of the key people in funky were doing grime, and there is a rough-and-ready quality to their production that recalls early grime tunes. There's a funky remake of the seminal grime 8-bar tune, "Pulse X" by Musical Mobb. I thought that was as far back as the homages went in funky but Tim Finney tells me there's actually a funky tune that samples LFO.
the necessity for paradigm shifts:
If we do think of any given phase within the continuum as a "game terrain", you could also talk of how all the permutations of any given game get exhausted -- leading to need for the rules of the game to be changed, for a new game to start. Hence speed garage -- which eclipsed drum'n'bass as the new game in town.
genre-not-genres versus the Nuum.
A certain kind of space opens up in mid-90s music -- the space whose different areas at different times have names like IDM, illbient, drill and bass, and which carries on in the Noughties with breakcore and most recently wonky. People in this zone draw from everything and takes pride in drawing from everything (or almost everything, there are always deaf spots and things too uncool to be on the menu). You could call this space post-rave music or post-techno. Now this space might generate quite a lot of listenable music and interesting talk, but I have to reiterate this point I've made in Energy Flash which is that this whole area is reliant on hardcore genres (not just the UK hardcore genres, but everything from gabba to the various global ghetto tech/shanty house genres to crunk and hyphy and various city-based street rap sounds), reliant on these sounds to come up with new ideas for it to "warp". Specifically in terms of the UK hardcore continuum, I really find it hard to believe that there will ever be a reversal of this one-way traffic in ideas. Can you imagine a nuum genre borrowing an idea from this area, from figures in Squarepusher/Rupture/Rustie mold?It's just not going to happen. I mean to say it never has happened, has it?
Using wonky to bash the continuum, it's like taking a wooden mallet to a mountain range. You'll just end up with a handful of splinters. A shame too because as mallets go it's a perfectly fetching little implement! Some great tunes there. But they do tend to remind me of all the records I bought in the 90s on labels like Clear or Sabatage. Eclectro some called it; there was an Eighties retro vibe even then. There's one in particular on Clear by an outfit called Clatterfunk I think it was that was from 1996 but using all these very mid-80s drum sounds and sequencing and synth timbres--ahead of its time by being behind of its time. I'm not saying that Clatterfunk is the same as wonky, but the essential move being made is the same.
Grime: Dead or Alive?
People often tick me off for declaring grime is dead, which is not what I said, not really… I said my own massive emotional investment in it shriveled when the genre itself seemed to shrivel, psychologically-speaking. Its expansionist drive, its thrust to conquer the pop charts, petered out, or came to naught. Here's the two salient posts, the first about what a grime that had settled for permanent underground status could possibly be like:
and here talking, entirely subjectively, about my desire for a clean break, like after a heartbreak
In response, certain people denied that pop breakthrough and chart dominance was ever a concern of grime's (which is patent bollocks, just listen to the lyrics in 2003-2005!), they said it was fine and dandy for grime to survive as a micro-culture, steadily rolling out quality material.
To which my response is : ooooo-kay, if you're REALLY happy with that…. I just find it hard to believe that anyone who ever really BELIEVED in grime didn't want it to conquer the world…
But of course in the last year we've seen how much grimesters do want to be stars, by the depths to which they've stooped to have hits!
I do think that "you can't stop us, we're coming through, we're blowing up" energy was actually a huge part of the content of grime as music, and when that was blocked, something went from the music. I check into grime now and then, hear some good stuff, but overall it doesn't seem to blazing with the same spirit. It's become a steady-state thing now, homeostasis; a settled, stable micro-culture.
Another factor affecting my response to what happened with grime is that because I am a thinker about music, I need to have new ideas to keep my interest up and a music that isn't going through changes doesn't enable me to say new stuff. So I'd freely admit it's a distorted relationship with music I have, to some extent. There are doubtless a fair few genres of music that have settled down and still produce "quality" but my interest has faded. I do tend to prefer the early surge phase of a scene or a sound.
Here's something I wrote in the autumn of 2007 on the tenth anniversary of UK garage, comparing it with jungle and treating the Nuum as "a game of two halves":
"…looking back at its decade so far, [UK garage's] legacy seems remarkably rich.
Compare it to where jungle was by its tenth birthday (let's say, for the sake of argument, 2003) and the progeny it had spawned (drum’n’bass… long before 2003, nothing to be particularly proud of; erm…. does breakcore count?), compared with UKG’s incarnations and offshoots (2step, dubstep, grime, bassline). There’s no contest, really. And UK Garage is in surprisingly fine fettle in its tenth (or is it eleventh?) year. Dubstep, getting a bit formulaic perhaps, but still throwing out fabulous records like the new Burial and Pinch’s debut. Grime, ticking along, probably in better shape than bruised believers like myself would want to acknowledge. And then bassline, throbbing with obscene life."
A lot of misunderstandings of my position are based on the fact that I approach things from two angles simultaneously in most of my writings on the nuum. One is the historian/journalist/amateur sociologist aspect; the other is the fan/critic. So it's two different registers -- objective versus subjective, dispassionate versus enthusiast (but of course enthusiasm can easily become disappointment or frustration). So for instance on the one hand the historian/objective approach tells me that dubstep and funky are very much part of or closely related to the Nuum. The fan/partisan, whose allegiance is based on the hardcore/jungle/ukgarage/grime stretch of the nuum, can equally, simultaneously be ambivalent about, or outright disappointed by those sounds. If I was just blindly pro anything that comes out of London/the nuum I'd not have voiced the various misgivings or frustrations I have about dubstep and funky, or indeed (in the past) about various directions or faction-sounds within jungle.
the Nuum on its 20th birthday: many happy returns?
The latest metaphor that feels potentially "true" to me is the idea of the Nuum as a star. The four-way collision of house/reggae/techno/hip hop was like the birth of a star. Which then blazed fiercely for a long, long time, throwing off lumps of gas that cool into planets (like drum'n'bass, happy hardcore etc). But the current phase of the nuum's existence is like a dwarf star--I'm not too sharp on my astrophysics but I think the precise analogy would be with a white dwarf. i.e. still a fairly substantial stellar body and generating some heat but it's used up most of its resources, and the future doesn't look so bright for it. I'd love to be convinced out of this scenario though!
Acknowledgements: big shout to Mark Fisher, hold it down... big shouts to Martin Clark and Luke Davis, rude boy for years, believe... big shout going out to Heva for inviting me in the first place.
The podcast of this talk --with slide-show of flyers, labels and other rave ephemera--- + the dialogue with Mark Fisher + audience Q/A is available at FACT TV http://fact.tv/videos/watch/518
viewer comments and my replies at the FACT website
4 Major Fallacies About the Hardcore Continuum (plus details of the April 2009 Nuum Seminar at University of East London)
The Hardcore Continuum series of articles in The Wire, 1992 to 2005
Posted by SIMON REYNOLDS at 10:37 AM 10 comments:
Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)